| 00:18.17 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-52-68-92.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 00:19.54 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 00:38.01 | *** join/#asterisk mmlj4 (~mmlj4@47-48-196-90.static.gwnt.ga.charter.com) |
| 01:19.58 | lvlinux | I'm not opposed to microtik purely for the fact that it isn't open source---my beef is not wanting to deal with licenses, etc. If it goes down for some reason, I just want to be able to grab some hardware I already have (of which i have a lot) and slap the same router OS on it without a bunch of issue. That is my only reason for wanting open source. |
| 01:21.27 | lvlinux | And if there is a feature that handles bufferbloat, but also lets me setup proper queing, similar to fq_codel, I'd be open to it. |
| 01:21.53 | lvlinux | pfSense QoS is ok, but not fantastic. |
| 01:22.27 | lorsungcu | lvlinux: what are you talking about re: licenses? |
| 01:23.32 | lorsungcu | there is no license required to import a configuration. licenses are included with any routerboard, and do not expire. |
| 01:23.51 | lorsungcu | if you prefer to use something other than their hardware, you can without issue. |
| 01:24.34 | lvlinux | well, maybe I'm misunderstanding the way Microtik stuff works idk. But anything that has an expiry period and then requires some sort of licensing is usually a pain to reinstall. |
| 01:24.53 | lorsungcu | lvlinux: licenses are included with any routerboard, and do not expire. |
| 01:25.18 | lvlinux | yeah but what about on other hardware, then what am I dealing with. |
| 01:25.19 | lorsungcu | there is no need to re-license, renew, un-license, etc. |
| 01:25.26 | lorsungcu | there is no difference between models. |
| 01:25.44 | lorsungcu | unless you're an ISP and are moving between hardware hosting thousands of tunnels or something |
| 01:26.29 | lorsungcu | you can take your config from router a and move it freely to router b |
| 01:26.46 | lorsungcu | everything will work, aside from itnerface-specific changes |
| 01:27.08 | lorsungcu | you will never need to touch the license. |
| 01:27.27 | lorsungcu | or anything approaching any form of a license. there is no limit to software upgrades, firmware upgrades, etc. |
| 01:27.45 | lvlinux | And I'm even not against buying a box like a Ubiquiti or Microtik, or Juniper or whatever, but I assumed that surely there is a good, enterprise-capable style router distro that is out there? (Like pfSense should be be evidently isn't) |
| 01:28.27 | lorsungcu | yes |
| 01:28.48 | lorsungcu | it's called linux, and it uses iptables |
| 01:28.58 | lorsungcu | it's opensource and well documented |
| 01:29.08 | lorsungcu | works on almost any hardware |
| 01:30.12 | lvlinux | of course lol, I did that for years, but now for my router, I would prefer something already tailored, that I don't have to mess with. (like pfSense but that actually WORKS) |
| 01:31.19 | lorsungcu | so you'd like routeros but don't want to pay |
| 01:31.33 | lvlinux | I guess I'm complaining like a noob, just got my dander up a little when I asked a legit question and then got hit by the RouterOS fanboys. lol |
| 01:31.46 | lorsungcu | not a fanboy, i dont care what you use |
| 01:31.58 | lorsungcu | wouldnt have said anything except what you did say was wrong |
| 01:32.01 | Samot | WTF |
| 01:32.05 | Samot | You asked for a suggestion. |
| 01:32.08 | Samot | I gave you one. |
| 01:32.10 | Samot | That was it. |
| 01:32.17 | Samot | Then you picked it apart. |
| 01:32.23 | Samot | I didn't fanboy on you. |
| 01:32.35 | lorsungcu | yeah we leave that to drmessano |
| 01:32.48 | Samot | I recommended a router that I would recommend to _anyone_ because of how it works and functions plus the cost. |
| 01:33.39 | lvlinux | lol ok whatever |
| 01:33.42 | drmessano | Fanboyism? lvlinux |
| 01:33.47 | Samot | Pardon me? |
| 01:33.48 | drmessano | It's called using what works |
| 01:34.38 | drmessano | I bet I've been through more router distros than you even know exist |
| 01:34.41 | drmessano | Just saying |
| 01:35.11 | lorsungcu | hell i even went a stint trying to fit in at ##pfsense |
| 01:35.42 | lorsungcu | pictured to prove it: https://i.imgflip.com/1p74ap.jpg |
| 01:35.54 | lvlinux | lol |
| 01:36.39 | lvlinux | so I guess what I'm wanting doesn't exist. |
| 01:36.47 | lorsungcu | idk what you want |
| 01:36.56 | lorsungcu | i cant be bothered to scroll up that far |
| 01:37.05 | drmessano | Well if you're a hobbyist just keep looking and loading distros |
| 01:37.18 | drmessano | I like a working router |
| 01:37.28 | lorsungcu | if you are just burning through distros, and really just want it to be oss and whatever |
| 01:37.32 | Samot | 5:29:51 PMÂ <lvlinux>Â Any suggestions for an open source router/firewall distro that runs on standard x86 hardware? I'm considering ditching pfSense since it appears Samot was right about it dropping/mangling my RTP packets for no good reason, and without notification. |
| 01:37.37 | lorsungcu | then use iptables and be done with it |
| 01:37.42 | Samot | ^^^ That's how I started to "fanboy" hi. |
| 01:37.43 | lorsungcu | or wahtever the newfangled thing is |
| 01:37.44 | Samot | ^^^ That's how I started to "fanboy" him. |
| 01:38.31 | drmessano | Samot: Probably best to ignore him. Just another angry troll |
| 01:38.32 | Samot | I purposefully ignored the "open source" part because they all have the same issues. |
| 01:39.00 | drmessano | Complaining that something doesn't something hard enough. Whatever |
| 01:39.07 | *** join/#asterisk Dovid (~dovid@ool-4573a525.dyn.optonline.net) |
| 01:39.20 | lvlinux | ??? idk where some of these ideas are coming from |
| 01:39.42 | drmessano | Should have stopped at "PFSense user" |
| 01:39.44 | Samot | lvlinux: OK, let us try this. What are you _actually_ looking for in your router? |
| 01:39.49 | drmessano | Because that says it all |
| 01:39.52 | lvlinux | Samot you didn't have to purposefully ignore the open source part, all you had to do was tell me "there aint none" |
| 01:40.01 | drmessano | It IMPLIES "troll" |
| 01:40.27 | lvlinux | ???? open source implies troll ?? lol where do u get that from? |
| 01:40.39 | drmessano | Huh? |
| 01:40.45 | drmessano | Scroll up |
| 01:40.53 | Samot | lvlinux: Are you going to answer my legitimate question? |
| 01:41.10 | Samot | Or continue on with whatever is happening right now? |
| 01:41.15 | drmessano | I said PFSENSE USER IMPLIES "TROLL" |
| 01:41.21 | drmessano | JFC |
| 01:41.28 | drmessano | ./ignore |
| 01:41.37 | lvlinux | ok let's start over: |
| 01:41.46 | drmessano | No let's not |
| 01:41.54 | drmessano | Ignoring you. Peace out |
| 01:42.07 | drmessano | Fkn troll |
| 01:42.20 | lvlinux | wow |
| 01:42.28 | drmessano | wanders off |
| 01:44.29 | Samot | Anyways, back to my question. |
| 01:44.46 | lvlinux | Ok to answer your question Samot, I'm looking for router software that runs on standard x86 hardware, full ipv6, openvpn, good QoS, and free if at all possible. |
| 01:45.07 | Samot | Those are the actual requirements? |
| 01:45.16 | Samot | Nothing about not mangling the hell out of your outbound packets? |
| 01:45.39 | lvlinux | Well I figured it was implied that that wasn't a desirable feature :) |
| 01:45.49 | Samot | Well |
| 01:46.07 | Samot | Not one of those requirements are SIP support/enable/optimize features. |
| 01:46.23 | Samot | Those are basically features so you can run this off an old XP machine that you put linux on. |
| 01:47.11 | lvlinux | Yes, I've done that, but I'd prefer it to be a distro of some sort that can be installed easily, config restored etc, for the purposes of changing machines. |
| 01:48.03 | lvlinux | And the only reason I want it to be free is for the convenience of having it on a thumb drive or whatever and just being able to slap it on a machine in a pinch, without worrying about purchasing a license, etc. |
| 01:48.29 | Samot | So, I don't think I can't help. |
| 01:48.30 | lvlinux | If that doesn't exist, then just tell me, but I didn't think my requirements were that outlandish. |
| 01:49.00 | Samot | I'm not a router hobbyist. |
| 01:49.15 | drmessano | Tried to point that out earlier |
| 01:49.21 | lvlinux | so you're saying you don't belive it exists. |
| 01:49.27 | Samot | I find routers that meet my requirements/needs and I use that |
| 01:49.36 | Samot | If it does, I don't know about it. |
| 01:49.54 | Samot | Routers/firewalls are not something I do in a "hobby" format. |
| 01:51.04 | drmessano | Guess you're not a thumb drive router hobbyist then and you don't "get it". |
| 01:51.13 | Samot | Not even my home router because I work from home and it is too important. |
| 01:51.36 | lvlinux | This is actually for my home router, but I like to use the same thing everywhere. |
| 01:51.36 | drmessano | Yeah |
| 01:51.44 | drmessano | Lol |
| 01:51.46 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 01:51.54 | Samot | When you say "everywhere" you mean commercially? |
| 01:51.56 | Samot | As a service? |
| 01:52.00 | drmessano | Oprah Firewall |
| 01:52.10 | drmessano | You get a router |
| 01:52.17 | lvlinux | small/medium sized business. |
| 01:52.27 | drmessano | Everyone gets a router |
| 01:52.33 | Samot | Yeah, then I really can't help. |
| 01:52.35 | drmessano | OprahFirewall |
| 01:52.48 | Samot | I would never deploy something rated as "hobbyist" for an actual service. |
| 01:52.50 | drmessano | Because Mikrotik doesn't fit that role |
| 01:52.54 | drmessano | I expensively |
| 01:53.00 | drmessano | Inexpensively |
| 01:53.03 | drmessano | Reliably |
| 01:53.10 | drmessano | At all |
| 01:53.17 | drmessano | #fanboy |
| 01:54.01 | drmessano | But putting it on a thumb drive and driving around installing it everywhere. That's a thing |
| 01:54.03 | lorsungcu | plays with ROS as a hobby and installs them in businesses professionally |
| 01:54.19 | drmessano | Where's my Willy Wonka meme |
| 01:54.36 | lvlinux | lol i know I've come across probably that way lol. |
| 01:55.08 | Samot | I would never use something like pfSense, OpenWRT or DD-WRT routers for business services. |
| 01:55.24 | Samot | The point of it all is that the end user wants a guarantee of uptime. |
| 01:55.32 | lorsungcu | screw the user |
| 01:55.41 | lorsungcu | who wants to maintain that? |
| 01:56.04 | Samot | If they are paying you to provide a professional service, do not deploy hobbyist hardware/software |
| 01:56.34 | Samot | Even beyond that |
| 01:56.51 | Samot | Don't do thinks like install "bleeding-edge" stuff that could break at anytime. |
| 01:56.59 | Samot | s/thinks/things/ |
| 01:57.04 | lorsungcu | upgrading DDWRT, in my experience, has meant lighting the router on fire, going to best buy, getting the cheapest DLink there, realizing you can't install WRT on it, returning to best buy to find they wont take the now-bricked DLink back, going on amazon, buying the MOST EXPENSIVE linksys, finding out it does just fine without DDWRT, getting bored, repeating |
| 01:57.34 | drmessano | https://usercontent.irccloud-cdn.com/file/tDaBa3rX/IMG_1406.JPG |
| 01:57.40 | lvlinux | I'm fully familiar with best practices re installing quality stuff at customer sites/not going bleeding edge, etc. I (wrongly) had assumed that pfSense was a pro level router. In my previous couple of installations where I have tried it, it has behaved nicely, and so and so big corp uses it here and there (US Air Force and whatnot). |
| 01:58.01 | Samot | x86 arch though |
| 01:58.01 | lvlinux | drmessano: lol that's great---I'm gonna have to keep that one. |
| 01:58.06 | lorsungcu | lvlinux: the air force does not use pfsense. |
| 01:58.16 | lorsungcu | someone, somewhere, in the AF installed it, on something |
| 01:58.18 | lorsungcu | that's it |
| 01:58.22 | lorsungcu | ffs. |
| 01:58.24 | lvlinux | well duh |
| 01:58.36 | lvlinux | i just used that for an dufus example... |
| 01:58.38 | Samot | Come on, pfSense users already went on a mass suicide pack over the move to ARM |
| 01:58.59 | lorsungcu | lvlinux: are you in the US |
| 01:59.51 | lvlinux | i don't keep up with political router community junk, i just (obviously wrongly) assumed that there was enterprise grade stuff based on Linux or BSD out there that was free and would meet my needs. But I guess not, so I'm gonna have to restudy my options. |
| 01:59.55 | lvlinux | lorsungcu: yes |
| 02:00.13 | lvlinux | what are the benefits of RouterOS vs Ubiquiti? |
| 02:00.21 | lorsungcu | ubiquiti drops your UDP packets |
| 02:00.28 | lorsungcu | so the traffic is lighter |
| 02:00.31 | lorsungcu | adn you can use smaller cables |
| 02:00.33 | lvlinux | like pfSense? |
| 02:00.36 | lvlinux | lol |
| 02:01.57 | lorsungcu | yes but different reasons |
| 02:02.06 | lorsungcu | vyatta is very good |
| 02:02.13 | lorsungcu | and likely meets your requirements |
| 02:02.19 | lorsungcu | but is nasty complex |
| 02:03.30 | lvlinux | i don't really mind complex, but prefer simpler. |
| 02:03.48 | drmessano | Please keep installing router distros on crappy x86 machines. I get a lot of business replacing those with Mikrotik boxes. Every little bit helps. Thx |
| 02:05.15 | lvlinux | lol |
| 02:06.05 | Samot | lvlinux: He's not joking. |
| 02:06.18 | Samot | I didn't really want to do networking |
| 02:06.27 | Samot | I didn't want to have to deal with routers. |
| 02:06.38 | Samot | But because people kept installing crappy routers... |
| 02:06.43 | lvlinux | I started with networking and moved into voip. |
| 02:06.45 | Samot | It would break my voice services.. |
| 02:06.53 | Samot | Oh.. |
| 02:07.03 | Samot | I've been dealing with networks for 20+ years |
| 02:07.17 | Samot | There is a difference between being able and wanting to do something |
| 02:07.46 | Samot | I ended up using MTs because they were suggested to me. |
| 02:07.54 | Samot | Oddly enough by lorsungcu and drmessano |
| 02:07.57 | lvlinux | i come from dealing with Cisco routers, but they're power hungry for the house lol. Ok I guess you guys have given me enough impetus I'm going to try RouterOS. |
| 02:08.06 | Samot | And I started to replace the crappy routers that were causing all my voice issues |
| 02:08.13 | Samot | And boom, my voice issues went away |
| 02:08.28 | lvlinux | thanks for all the input that was helpful everyone. I really didn't mean to start a flame deal... |
| 02:08.33 | Samot | hEX Lite = 2W power |
| 02:14.57 | drmessano | Fanboy |
| 02:15.15 | Samot | Well I looked it up. |
| 02:15.33 | Samot | Because wattage was being tossed around earlier. |
| 02:42.43 | snadge | threadripper cpu.. 180W |
| 02:42.44 | snadge | :P |
| 02:44.52 | lorsungcu | i want it and i dont know why |
| 02:47.38 | snadge | yeah same.. i just dont want to pay 2 grand for the motherboard and cpu (Australian) |
| 02:47.41 | drmessano | Basically.. it looks cool as shit to assemble |
| 02:47.49 | drmessano | But like, then you're done |
| 02:47.52 | drmessano | and just have a computer |
| 02:48.00 | snadge | one with beast specs |
| 02:48.14 | snadge | 16 cores, 32 threads.. 64 pci-e lanes.. quad channel ddr4 memory.. dayum |
| 02:48.25 | drmessano | I can play Minecraft with a hercules graphics card |
| 02:48.28 | drmessano | No big deal |
| 02:50.09 | drmessano | Speaking of which |
| 02:50.15 | drmessano | I can finally update to 1.12 |
| 02:56.24 | snadge | the threadripper would probably be good for playing minecraft 16 times |
| 02:56.33 | snadge | .. simultaneously |
| 02:56.55 | snadge | or streaming it on twitch |
| 02:57.00 | snadge | whilst encoding a video |
| 02:57.11 | snadge | and cracking some passwords |
| 02:57.46 | snadge | im gonna be curious how many people buy threadrippers because they need them.. vs.. because they want one and don't know why :p |
| 03:30.40 | *** join/#asterisk u0m3_ (~u0m3@5-12-198-162.residential.rdsnet.ro) |
| 03:42.29 | *** join/#asterisk mmlj4 (~mmlj4@47-48-196-90.static.gwnt.ga.charter.com) |
| 03:43.15 | *** join/#asterisk Gullibaer (~Signor_Ro@ip-109-90-16-90.hsi11.unitymediagroup.de) |
| 03:43.56 | *** part/#asterisk Gullibaer (~Signor_Ro@ip-109-90-16-90.hsi11.unitymediagroup.de) |
| 04:06.19 | *** join/#asterisk skywayskase (~skywayska@163.182.162.226) |
| 04:09.50 | *** join/#asterisk sragan (~skywayska@163.182.162.226) |
| 04:33.19 | *** join/#asterisk mmlj4 (~mmlj4@47-48-196-90.static.gwnt.ga.charter.com) |
| 04:34.44 | *** join/#asterisk mmlj4 (~mmlj4@47-48-196-90.static.gwnt.ga.charter.com) |
| 04:38.50 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 04:44.34 | *** join/#asterisk gerhard7 (~gerhard7@ip5657ee30.direct-adsl.nl) |
| 04:46.29 | *** join/#asterisk FarhaadN (~Farhad@82.99.206.194) |
| 04:47.26 | FarhaadN | hi , in asterisk 13 , i send any dtmf on cisco, and asterisk get 3 dtmf , why? |
| 04:47.41 | FarhaadN | i test in asterisk 1.8 and work fine |
| 04:49.45 | drmessano | Cisco what |
| 04:54.23 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 05:03.40 | lorsungcu | cisco whaaaaaaaaaat |
| 05:08.52 | *** join/#asterisk NightMonkey (~NightMonk@pdpc/supporter/professional/nightmonkey) |
| 05:09.33 | drmessano | FarhaadN: |
| 05:13.49 | FarhaadN | drmessano: i dont know what cisco |
| 05:13.58 | drmessano | Say what? |
| 05:14.00 | FarhaadN | but i know E1 |
| 05:14.08 | FarhaadN | call from E1 |
| 05:14.08 | drmessano | ????? |
| 05:14.20 | drmessano | "I send any DTMF on cisco" |
| 05:14.30 | drmessano | What is this "cisco" |
| 05:14.31 | FarhaadN | yes cisco |
| 05:14.34 | drmessano | You named a BRAND |
| 05:14.38 | drmessano | Not a DEVICE |
| 05:14.47 | drmessano | Paint the PICTURE |
| 05:14.53 | FarhaadN | but i dont access to it |
| 05:14.59 | drmessano | .... |
| 05:15.07 | drmessano | You did this last time you were here |
| 05:15.13 | drmessano | So im gonna give you one chance, dude |
| 05:15.19 | drmessano | Complete sentences |
| 05:15.29 | drmessano | "I send any DTMF on cisco" |
| 05:15.41 | FarhaadN | wait to ask |
| 05:15.50 | drmessano | That's a horribly incomplete statement |
| 05:16.21 | drmessano | Is this a CISCO PHONE? |
| 05:16.24 | drmessano | IS it using SIP? |
| 05:16.26 | drmessano | SKINNY? |
| 05:16.28 | FarhaadN | i have very complete statement |
| 05:16.31 | drmessano | PAINT THE PICTURE |
| 05:16.35 | FarhaadN | but my language is week |
| 05:16.43 | FarhaadN | so i cant explan well |
| 05:16.48 | drmessano | Yep, you said that last time too |
| 05:16.50 | drmessano | DETAILS |
| 05:16.58 | drmessano | FUcking supply DETAILS |
| 05:17.03 | drmessano | Dont make US PULL THEM FROM YOU |
| 05:18.07 | FarhaadN | so You do not have to answer that |
| 05:18.30 | Samot | FarhaadN: No one can help you if you do not provide details. |
| 05:19.38 | FarhaadN | drmessano: be quiet and let other peaple help without any Protest |
| 05:20.16 | drmessano | Thats two people telling you to provide details |
| 05:20.21 | drmessano | Stop being so rude |
| 05:21.10 | FarhaadN | Samot: I try to explane that , but is not necessary to make fun of |
| 05:21.39 | Samot | Did I make fun of anything? |
| 05:21.42 | Samot | No I did not. |
| 05:22.10 | Samot | But I'm also not going to do the same thing we always do... |
| 05:22.12 | drmessano | Now we're virtue signalling |
| 05:22.28 | Samot | Which is I spend more of my time trying to get actual details than fixing the problem. |
| 05:22.39 | FarhaadN | drmessano ask me what cisco, and i tell him i dont know what model |
| 05:22.48 | Samot | OK |
| 05:22.50 | drmessano | Is it a PHONE |
| 05:22.51 | Samot | Then we cannot help. |
| 05:22.52 | drmessano | IS IT A PBX |
| 05:22.55 | drmessano | IS IT SIP |
| 05:22.58 | drmessano | IS IT SCCP |
| 05:22.59 | FarhaadN | cisco gateway |
| 05:23.01 | drmessano | WHAT IS IT? |
| 05:23.07 | drmessano | Cisco Gateway |
| 05:23.07 | Samot | If you do not know the model of the phone you are having an issue with, we can't do anything. |
| 05:23.09 | drmessano | Wow |
| 05:23.10 | drmessano | Because |
| 05:23.14 | drmessano | I would have guessed a phone |
| 05:23.19 | drmessano | and been WRONG |
| 05:23.22 | Samot | Yup. |
| 05:23.23 | drmessano | Because I had to GUESS |
| 05:23.28 | drmessano | JFC |
| 05:23.42 | drmessano | FarhaadN: IS IT SIP? |
| 05:23.44 | FarhaadN | i told u i call E1 |
| 05:23.45 | drmessano | IS IT SCCP? |
| 05:23.52 | drmessano | No you didn't |
| 05:24.06 | drmessano | You said you know E1 |
| 05:24.09 | FarhaadN | (9:43:46 AM) FarhaadN: drmessano: i dont know what cisco |
| 05:24.09 | FarhaadN | (9:43:56 AM) drmessano: Say what? |
| 05:24.09 | FarhaadN | (9:43:57 AM) FarhaadN: but i know E1 |
| 05:24.09 | FarhaadN | (9:44:05 AM) FarhaadN: call from E1 |
| 05:24.23 | drmessano | You didn't say |
| 05:24.30 | drmessano | "It's a Cisco Gateway, call is from E1" |
| 05:24.39 | drmessano | Like, you know, a complete fucking thought |
| 05:25.01 | FarhaadN | and i trunk between it and my asterisk |
| 05:25.03 | FarhaadN | sip trunk |
| 05:25.08 | FarhaadN | its complete? |
| 05:25.19 | drmessano | Ok |
| 05:25.20 | drmessano | Well |
| 05:25.35 | drmessano | Where is ANY DTMF being pressed? |
| 05:25.41 | drmessano | Obviously not "from the cisco" |
| 05:25.43 | drmessano | So where? |
| 05:26.25 | drmessano | So if you're even telling the whole story |
| 05:26.42 | drmessano | E1 <----> Cisco Gateway <----SIP----> Asterisk |
| 05:26.57 | drmessano | Incorrect DTMF is not Asterisk's problem |
| 05:27.06 | drmessano | Unless you're using INBAND |
| 05:27.09 | drmessano | In which case, don't |
| 05:27.15 | drmessano | RFC2833 |
| 05:27.47 | FarhaadN | when i call E1 and recive to my asterisk , it go to ivr and in ivr i have 4 key (1,2,3,90) , when i enter 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 , in asterisk cli , show me call try too connect extention 111 or 222 or ... |
| 05:28.27 | drmessano | LOL |
| 05:28.43 | drmessano | That a config problem on the Cisco |
| 05:28.54 | FarhaadN | whit same config |
| 05:29.23 | FarhaadN | install elastix 2.5 with asterisk 1.8 |
| 05:29.25 | drmessano | RFC2833 |
| 05:29.30 | FarhaadN | and whit same config |
| 05:29.33 | FarhaadN | that work |
| 05:30.03 | drmessano | Stop using inband DTMF |
| 05:30.18 | FarhaadN | w8 i send u my sip config |
| 05:30.25 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 05:31.23 | drmessano | SIP doesn't have tone duration |
| 05:32.09 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/UZgFs5DA |
| 05:33.39 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/tJ0femSp > dtmf log from one press |
| 05:35.03 | drmessano | How is the Cisco set up? |
| 05:35.23 | FarhaadN | i dont access to it |
| 05:35.32 | FarhaadN | but i can get |
| 05:35.40 | drmessano | It's set up for inband |
| 05:35.43 | FarhaadN | what part you need? |
| 05:36.05 | drmessano | Set the cisco for RFC2833 |
| 05:36.12 | FarhaadN | you say that problem is cisco? |
| 05:36.23 | FarhaadN | why in asterisk 1.8 it work? |
| 05:36.50 | FarhaadN | i can get cisco config, tell me what port you need to know? |
| 05:37.53 | drmessano | I just told you |
| 05:37.54 | drmessano | Twice |
| 05:37.57 | drmessano | Set the cisco for RFC2833 |
| 05:38.11 | drmessano | It's currently set for INBAND |
| 05:39.31 | FarhaadN | beacause i should told cisco manager to do that, i need for know what meaning |
| 05:39.42 | drmessano | huh? |
| 05:39.46 | drmessano | DTMF INBAND IS BAD |
| 05:39.51 | drmessano | Dont use it |
| 05:39.53 | drmessano | Ever |
| 05:39.57 | drmessano | Thats the meaning |
| 05:40.01 | *** join/#asterisk emk (~emk@unaffiliated/emk) |
| 05:40.12 | FarhaadN | okk |
| 05:40.36 | FarhaadN | i told chang dtmf inband to rfc2833 |
| 05:40.42 | FarhaadN | its ok? |
| 05:40.45 | *** join/#asterisk justdave (~dave@unaffiliated/justdave) |
| 05:40.50 | drmessano | For the 4th time, yes |
| 05:40.52 | lorsungcu | ok with me |
| 05:41.19 | FarhaadN | drmessano: tank you |
| 05:42.34 | FarhaadN | and forgive me if affend you |
| 05:50.57 | FarhaadN | drmessano: he told me tdmf config is set rfc2833 |
| 05:51.01 | FarhaadN | from begining |
| 05:52.25 | drmessano | Then he has the E1 config wrong |
| 05:54.22 | lorsungcu | or |
| 05:54.44 | lorsungcu | your extension is sending inband and something weird is happening elsewhere |
| 05:55.52 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/GRE278fu |
| 05:55.57 | FarhaadN | send me this from cisco |
| 05:57.00 | FarhaadN | drmessano: what part need from config? |
| 05:57.17 | FarhaadN | lorsungcu: send you extention_additional config? |
| 05:57.25 | lorsungcu | no |
| 05:57.29 | lorsungcu | you can check this |
| 05:57.30 | drmessano | You said this call is coming FROM the E1, right? |
| 05:57.30 | *** join/#asterisk evil_gordita (robert@ip70-188-41-127.rn.hr.cox.net) |
| 05:57.33 | drmessano | TO THE IVR? |
| 05:57.47 | FarhaadN | yes come from E1 |
| 05:57.53 | FarhaadN | and in my asterisk , go to ivr |
| 05:58.15 | lorsungcu | turn off relaxdtmf |
| 05:58.28 | lorsungcu | i thought this was going out for some reason |
| 05:59.32 | FarhaadN | ok i turn off relaxdtmf on sip trunk and sip.conf |
| 06:00.54 | lorsungcu | FarhaadN: stop touching config files |
| 06:00.56 | lorsungcu | you're using elastix |
| 06:01.02 | lorsungcu | only use the GUI |
| 06:01.28 | FarhaadN | no i use freepbx |
| 06:01.39 | FarhaadN | in elastix everything is ok |
| 06:01.44 | FarhaadN | with elastix 2.5 |
| 06:01.56 | lorsungcu | go to #freepbx |
| 06:02.00 | FarhaadN | ok |
| 06:02.13 | *** join/#asterisk DanB (~DanB@178.138.96.62) |
| 06:03.17 | drmessano | FarhaadN: dtmf-interworking rtp-nte |
| 06:03.30 | drmessano | Need to be set on the peer on the cisco |
| 06:03.59 | FarhaadN | dont turn off relaxdtmf? |
| 06:04.06 | drmessano | You need dtmf-relay rtp-nte |
| 06:04.07 | drmessano | and |
| 06:04.12 | drmessano | dtmf-interworking rtp-nte |
| 06:05.55 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/UAvjTUGn |
| 06:06.01 | FarhaadN | is that ok? |
| 06:07.17 | FarhaadN | and dont turn of relaxdtmf? |
| 06:07.21 | drmessano | Hang on, one second.. I think one of these is wrong |
| 06:07.33 | drmessano | You're only supposed to enable translation one way |
| 06:08.39 | drmessano | FarhaadN: Need to remove the dtmf-interworking AND the dtmf-relay command from the E1 side |
| 06:08.51 | drmessano | Those only need to be on the Asterisk peer side |
| 06:09.40 | FarhaadN | can you please send me corrent configuration? |
| 06:09.40 | drmessano | If you put a relay on both sides, it's putting dtmf from inband <> rfc2833 on both sides, effectively doubling it |
| 06:09.51 | drmessano | I told you |
| 06:10.03 | drmessano | Remove those 2 lines from the E1 side of the config |
| 06:10.22 | drmessano | Only the E1 |
| 06:10.50 | FarhaadN | ok i told him |
| 06:11.17 | FarhaadN | outbound call from my asterisk to out , also ok? |
| 06:12.51 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/PzmUJUdz > i send to him that config , ok? |
| 06:13.19 | drmessano | I think thats fine |
| 06:13.25 | FarhaadN | ok i check it now |
| 06:18.51 | FarhaadN | its okkkk for e1 |
| 06:19.22 | FarhaadN | tank you |
| 06:19.36 | drmessano | So its working as expected now? |
| 06:19.51 | FarhaadN | but another issue is for SIP Trunk |
| 06:20.10 | FarhaadN | drmessano: yes remove those from 2 side and ok |
| 06:20.37 | FarhaadN | but in sip trunk issue still exist |
| 06:21.24 | drmessano | Im confused.. you have an E1 AND a SIP trunk? |
| 06:21.37 | FarhaadN | yes , wait explane to you |
| 06:22.30 | FarhaadN | <my asterisk> ---sip trunk--- < cisco > ----sip trunk---- <TCI> |
| 06:22.49 | FarhaadN | <my asterisk> ---sip trunk--- < cisco > ----E1---- <TCI> |
| 06:23.03 | FarhaadN | E1 is ok from now |
| 06:24.01 | FarhaadN | the same dial-peer on cisco , for sip trunk dosent work |
| 06:25.33 | drmessano | Oh |
| 06:25.45 | drmessano | Ok |
| 06:26.08 | drmessano | Its repeating digits on the SIP trunk from the Cisco, right? |
| 06:32.06 | FarhaadN | yes right |
| 06:32.15 | FarhaadN | sry for delay |
| 06:32.37 | *** join/#asterisk justdave (~dave@unaffiliated/justdave) |
| 06:32.46 | drmessano | Ok |
| 06:32.59 | drmessano | Then you need those settings on that config on the cisco |
| 06:33.16 | drmessano | < cisco > ----sip trunk---- <TCI> |
| 06:33.20 | drmessano | That config |
| 06:33.38 | drmessano | But NOT the config for the trunk to asterisk.. that's the important part |
| 06:34.55 | FarhaadN | no any config? |
| 06:35.11 | FarhaadN | so cisco how to know session target? |
| 06:35.52 | drmessano | You should have a peer in the Cisco for Asterisk |
| 06:35.57 | drmessano | and one for TCI |
| 06:36.08 | drmessano | the one on TCI needs to get those dtmf settings |
| 06:37.36 | FarhaadN | i think you tell i change last config ,and emty dtmf for asterisk , and add to trunk side |
| 06:38.08 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/enVLM7Z0 |
| 06:38.27 | FarhaadN | for example |
| 06:38.31 | FarhaadN | yes? |
| 06:41.58 | drmessano | Yes |
| 06:42.07 | drmessano | I think that's correct |
| 06:42.19 | drmessano | Been like 8 years since i've done Cisco voice configs |
| 06:42.37 | drmessano | But I know the dtmf settings go on the trunk and the E1 side |
| 06:42.50 | drmessano | the peer to asterisk DOES NOT get them |
| 06:43.01 | *** join/#asterisk [d__d] (~d__d]@ec2-54-85-45-223.compute-1.amazonaws.com) |
| 06:43.02 | drmessano | So it's not translating twice |
| 06:44.25 | FarhaadN | i told him , and i tell you result |
| 06:54.29 | FarhaadN | drmessano: dtmf not working |
| 06:54.52 | drmessano | On the SIP trunk? |
| 06:54.59 | drmessano | It's repeating or not working at all? |
| 06:54.59 | FarhaadN | yes |
| 06:55.05 | FarhaadN | not working at all |
| 06:55.14 | drmessano | Ah |
| 06:55.33 | FarhaadN | :-/ |
| 06:56.51 | drmessano | Ok |
| 06:56.52 | drmessano | So |
| 06:57.10 | drmessano | remove those lines so the trunk starts working again |
| 06:58.03 | drmessano | on the PEER to Asterisk do |
| 06:59.06 | drmessano | dtmf-relay rtp-nte digit-drop and dtmf-interworking rtp-nte |
| 06:59.15 | drmessano | dtmf-relay rtp-nte digit-drop |
| 07:00.50 | FarhaadN | (11:27:07 AM) drmessano: remove those lines so the trunk starts working again |
| 07:00.51 | FarhaadN | no |
| 07:01.05 | FarhaadN | when remove from sip trunk ,or asterisk side |
| 07:01.09 | FarhaadN | its not work |
| 07:01.19 | drmessano | Okay |
| 07:01.22 | drmessano | So |
| 07:01.31 | drmessano | Change the Asterisk side |
| 07:01.33 | FarhaadN | should but side exist to work |
| 07:01.34 | drmessano | dtmf-relay rtp-nte digit-drop |
| 07:01.41 | FarhaadN | ok |
| 07:01.55 | FarhaadN | and in sip trunk ? |
| 07:02.25 | drmessano | I dont know if you need it there, don't need it there, or if it needs to be BOTH places |
| 07:02.59 | drmessano | Basically you're trying to pass the INBAND > RFC2833 and not have it BOTH places |
| 07:03.04 | drmessano | So you need the right combination |
| 07:03.07 | FarhaadN | dtmf-interworking rtp-nte is need or not? |
| 07:03.15 | drmessano | Yes it's needed |
| 07:03.48 | drmessano | When you said it E1 was working |
| 07:04.00 | drmessano | That was after which change? |
| 07:06.02 | FarhaadN | yes i remove those dtmf |
| 07:06.06 | FarhaadN | from both side |
| 07:06.19 | FarhaadN | and send from he |
| 07:06.35 | drmessano | Ok, you remove those from BOTH sides the DTMF was fine from the E1? |
| 07:06.41 | FarhaadN | yes |
| 07:06.47 | drmessano | Okay.. THAT is important |
| 07:06.54 | drmessano | So |
| 07:07.06 | drmessano | You need those DTMF ONLY on the SIP to TCI |
| 07:07.24 | drmessano | That's where your issue is now |
| 07:07.36 | drmessano | dtmf-relay rtp-nte digit-drop |
| 07:07.49 | drmessano | dtmf-interworking rtp-nte |
| 07:12.11 | FarhaadN | ok but in last test |
| 07:12.47 | FarhaadN | when remove dtmf-relay rtp-nte from asterisk side, dtmf not working at all |
| 07:13.43 | FarhaadN | wait i send him this config https://pastebin.com/k5hsYdQT and check |
| 07:14.27 | FarhaadN | In your opinion its okey? or whithout asterisk dtmf side? |
| 07:15.31 | *** join/#asterisk pchero_work (~pchero@109.70.54.56) |
| 07:15.33 | drmessano | I think so |
| 07:16.27 | drmessano | You told me removing the dtmf settings fixed the E1 |
| 07:16.39 | FarhaadN | yes E1 |
| 07:16.40 | drmessano | are you saying you removed them from the E1 config and that fixed the E1 |
| 07:16.45 | FarhaadN | but in sip trunk no |
| 07:16.49 | drmessano | Okay |
| 07:16.58 | drmessano | That makes sense then |
| 07:17.09 | drmessano | So what you pastebin'ed would be my next try |
| 07:17.29 | FarhaadN | send to him? |
| 07:19.18 | drmessano | Yep |
| 07:25.12 | FarhaadN | not work |
| 07:25.31 | FarhaadN | dtmf work but wrong |
| 07:25.59 | drmessano | Okay |
| 07:26.03 | FarhaadN | and one thing , in e1 dtmf asterisk sid exist |
| 07:26.16 | FarhaadN | and e1 side not exist |
| 07:26.18 | FarhaadN | for work |
| 07:26.45 | FarhaadN | he told me now |
| 07:26.53 | drmessano | Ok, so for it work |
| 07:26.57 | drmessano | Not on E1 side |
| 07:27.07 | drmessano | dtmf-relay on Asterisk side |
| 07:27.09 | FarhaadN | yes , |
| 07:27.25 | FarhaadN | in this test |
| 07:27.42 | drmessano | So |
| 07:27.43 | FarhaadN | digit-drop add or remove for 2 side |
| 07:27.48 | FarhaadN | and not work fine |
| 07:27.56 | drmessano | Okay |
| 07:28.06 | drmessano | So put digit-drop on asterisk side |
| 07:28.18 | drmessano | and remove from trunk side |
| 07:28.39 | FarhaadN | i told him |
| 07:28.45 | FarhaadN | add in asterisk side |
| 07:28.48 | FarhaadN | and not work |
| 07:29.00 | FarhaadN | but i dont know , delete from trunk side or not |
| 07:29.23 | drmessano | I think he needs to make trunk side dtmf-relay rtp-nte WITHOUT digit-drop |
| 07:29.46 | drmessano | and WITH digit-drop on Asterisk |
| 07:30.12 | FarhaadN | i cant tell him change config any more :-/ |
| 07:30.19 | FarhaadN | this is last test? |
| 07:30.24 | *** join/#asterisk mmlj4 (~mmlj4@47-48-196-90.static.gwnt.ga.charter.com) |
| 07:30.27 | drmessano | Well, here is the deal |
| 07:30.30 | drmessano | We fixed the E1 side |
| 07:30.38 | drmessano | So we know it's a setting on the Cisco to fix the trunk |
| 07:30.41 | drmessano | So we know it's a setting on the Cisco to fix the SIP trunk |
| 07:30.54 | drmessano | So my last guess would be digit-drop on asterisk |
| 07:31.01 | drmessano | and not digit-drop on trunk |
| 07:31.49 | drmessano | If that doesn't do it, you or him are going to need to google some.. because that's all remember from 8 years ago :) |
| 07:31.50 | FarhaadN | ok i test that |
| 07:32.00 | FarhaadN | :D |
| 07:33.18 | FarhaadN | dtmf-interworking ? |
| 07:33.50 | FarhaadN | need for what side? |
| 07:34.48 | drmessano | both |
| 07:35.28 | FarhaadN | https://pastebin.com/jLHL5TBB |
| 07:35.29 | drmessano | dtmf-relay rtp-nte on trunk |
| 07:35.44 | drmessano | Right |
| 07:35.51 | drmessano | That would be my last guess |
| 07:36.08 | FarhaadN | wait to test |
| 07:42.23 | FarhaadN | his not available |
| 07:51.11 | FarhaadN | dont work fine |
| 07:52.20 | FarhaadN | drmessano: |
| 07:52.27 | drmessano | huh? |
| 07:53.38 | FarhaadN | whit last config not work fine |
| 07:53.56 | FarhaadN | and duplicate dtmf |
| 07:54.28 | drmessano | ok |
| 07:54.32 | drmessano | Well, time to google |
| 07:55.05 | *** join/#asterisk jkroon (~jkroon@uls-154-73-35-201.wall.uls.co.za) |
| 07:55.18 | drmessano | I really dont think those need to be on the SIP trunk AND Asterisk |
| 07:55.23 | drmessano | they contradict |
| 07:55.39 | drmessano | So you will need to experiment |
| 07:57.44 | *** join/#asterisk gtjoseph (~gtjoseph@unaffiliated/gtj) |
| 07:57.44 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o gtjoseph] by ChanServ |
| 07:58.27 | FarhaadN | experiment what? |
| 08:14.25 | drmessano | Google |
| 08:14.29 | drmessano | DTMF settings |
| 08:14.30 | drmessano | Cisco |
| 08:14.40 | drmessano | You need to experiment with those settings |
| 08:14.45 | drmessano | that is where the problem lies |
| 08:18.51 | FarhaadN | ok tanks , i try |
| 08:26.13 | *** join/#asterisk hehol (~hehol@gatekeeper.loca.net) |
| 08:31.40 | *** join/#asterisk jkroon (~jkroon@165.16.204.34) |
| 08:31.41 | *** join/#asterisk davlefou (~davlefou@unaffiliated/davlefou) |
| 08:34.47 | *** part/#asterisk FarhaadN (~Farhad@82.99.206.194) |
| 08:37.36 | *** join/#asterisk Kaian (~kaian@212.81.221.228) |
| 08:54.39 | *** join/#asterisk stefan27 (~stefan27@static-212-247-4-149.cust.tele2.se) |
| 09:15.14 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@193.180.18.201) |
| 09:18.59 | *** join/#asterisk cryptic (~cryptic@67-8-35-31.res.bhn.net) |
| 09:20.09 | *** join/#asterisk Dovid (~dovid@ool-4573a525.dyn.optonline.net) |
| 09:20.44 | *** join/#asterisk bipolar (~bipolar@offsite.guru) |
| 09:38.55 | *** join/#asterisk dnit (673399be@gateway/web/freenode/ip.103.51.153.190) |
| 09:41.07 | dnit | Hello, I am explicitly bridging my agent channel to another channel. I am using a hangup handler so that when the call ends my agent is put in holding bridge because of which asterisk logs out my agent, |
| 09:41.31 | dnit | IS there any way I can put my agent in agent_holding_bridge instead of basic_holding_bridge |
| 10:07.21 | *** join/#asterisk jjrh (~weechat12@ppp-199-167-117-128.storm.ca) |
| 10:38.02 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@193.180.18.201) |
| 10:46.15 | dnit | Hello, I am explicitly bridging my agent channel to another channel. I am using a hangup handler so that when the call ends my agent is put in holding bridge because of which asterisk logs out my agent, |
| 10:46.22 | dnit | IS there any way I can put my agent in agent_holding_bridge instead of basic_holding_bridge |
| 11:00.24 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-50-13-51.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 11:32.04 | *** join/#asterisk TandyUK2 (~admin@2a02:13a0:a006:1:b4f8:8786:220b:5d0f) |
| 11:38.54 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@193.180.18.201) |
| 12:12.45 | *** join/#asterisk nighty- (~nighty@s229123.ppp.asahi-net.or.jp) |
| 12:14.13 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@193.180.18.201) |
| 12:29.29 | *** join/#asterisk gerhard7 (~gerhard7@ip5657ee30.direct-adsl.nl) |
| 12:31.26 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 12:44.12 | *** join/#asterisk brad_mssw (~brad@66.129.88.50) |
| 12:55.45 | *** join/#asterisk mlhess (~mlhess@drupal.org/user/102818/view) |
| 13:15.05 | *** join/#asterisk [TK]D-Fender (~joe@216.191.106.165) |
| 13:15.22 | *** join/#asterisk newtonr (newtonr@nat/digium/x-gbqqtllbrdpdjyoh) |
| 13:15.22 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o newtonr] by ChanServ |
| 13:17.09 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-50-13-51.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 13:24.12 | *** join/#asterisk defswork (~aporter@212.38.66.116) |
| 13:24.53 | defswork | are asterisk call recordings real time or simple saved packets ? i.e. if there was packet flow issues would there be gaps ? |
| 13:33.02 | voipmonk | Hehe, what is rtp if not a flow of packets. |
| 13:37.38 | voipmonk | defswork, does any leg of the call use sip? |
| 13:38.07 | voipmonk | Does any leg of the call use rtp? |
| 13:38.15 | defswork | yes |
| 13:38.38 | defswork | voipmonk, I mean, if theres a rtp stream and theres a 3 second delay in the middle |
| 13:38.49 | defswork | is the call recording including the 3 second delay |
| 13:38.55 | Samot | Of course. |
| 13:39.03 | Samot | It is recording the AUDIO |
| 13:39.08 | defswork | or is it just saving packets - therefore the real time gap would be missing |
| 13:39.16 | Samot | So if there is a gap in the audio that would normally be heard, it will be there. |
| 13:39.27 | Samot | It's not saving packets. |
| 13:39.37 | Samot | It's recording an active, live, real time stream |
| 13:39.48 | defswork | right |
| 13:58.43 | *** join/#asterisk kharwell (kharwell@nat/digium/x-tgmyyhchyzlehypm) |
| 13:58.43 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o kharwell] by ChanServ |
| 13:59.20 | *** join/#asterisk bford (d8cff501@gateway/web/freenode/ip.216.207.245.1) |
| 13:59.21 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o bford] by ChanServ |
| 13:59.52 | dnit | Hello, I am explicitly bridging my agent channel to another channel. I am using a hangup handler so that when the call ends my agent is put in holding bridge because of which asterisk logs out my agent, |
| 14:00.00 | dnit | IS there any way I can put my agent in agent_holding_bridge instead of basic_holding_bridge |
| 14:04.12 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-52-120-216.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 14:07.58 | *** join/#asterisk jfcl (~jfcl`@modemcable162.109-37-24.static.videotron.ca) |
| 14:13.37 | *** join/#asterisk sommarna_ (~sommarnat@193.180.18.201) |
| 14:24.13 | *** join/#asterisk roukoswarf (znc@rouk.org) |
| 14:25.15 | *** join/#asterisk gerhard7 (~gerhard7@ip5657ee30.direct-adsl.nl) |
| 14:36.12 | *** join/#asterisk Dovid (~dovid@static-173-63-105-210.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) |
| 14:38.24 | *** join/#asterisk anpi (~crr@unaffiliated/anpi) |
| 14:39.48 | *** join/#asterisk roukoswarf (znc@rouk.org) |
| 14:40.10 | dnit | Hello. |
| 14:44.48 | *** part/#asterisk jfcl (~jfcl`@modemcable162.109-37-24.static.videotron.ca) |
| 14:49.42 | *** join/#asterisk evilman_work (~evilman@87.244.6.228) |
| 14:55.07 | *** join/#asterisk rmudgett (rmudgett@nat/digium/x-wesnkengogqfsbfn) |
| 14:55.07 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o rmudgett] by ChanServ |
| 15:03.45 | lvlinux | Hello dnit. |
| 15:03.49 | lvlinux | Goodbye dnit. |
| 15:03.58 | lvlinux | Patience dnit. |
| 15:03.59 | lvlinux | lol |
| 15:26.18 | wabbits | Come back dnit! |
| 15:33.00 | [TK]D-Fender | AZIZ LIGHT!!! |
| 15:48.06 | *** join/#asterisk ChkDigit (~u388mw@74.3.144.66) |
| 15:56.47 | *** join/#asterisk miralin (~Thunderbi@91.237.94.1) |
| 15:57.54 | *** join/#asterisk k3asd` (~k3asd@unaffiliated/k3asd/x-0305612) |
| 16:03.38 | k3asd` | hi there, I setted up 2 pbx by asterisk in a clustering mode (pacemaker, corosync, pcsd) - I added the resource as virtual ip and asterisk to be managed by pcsd. if I try singularly the pbx works fine. if both pbxs are under cluster I have issues like routing calls. when can I verify that? if you want some detail I'm available. thanks in advance |
| 16:08.20 | drmessano | Asterisk doesn't cluster |
| 16:09.01 | drmessano | You can have multiple boxes handing calls, but they need to be specifically routed as such |
| 16:12.08 | k3asd` | drmessano: how? |
| 16:12.26 | k3asd` | drmessano: can I do troubleshooting? |
| 16:12.30 | drmessano | I think you're missing what I am telling you |
| 16:12.34 | Samot | Troubleshooting on what? |
| 16:12.39 | lvlinux | with a SIP proxy like kamailio |
| 16:12.40 | drmessano | You can't do what you want to do |
| 16:12.53 | drmessano | 12:12:40 <lvlinux> with a SIP proxy like kamailio <--- that |
| 16:13.04 | Samot | Yup. |
| 16:13.08 | drmessano | But you can't just put two asterisk boxes in a cluster and expect magic |
| 16:13.12 | Samot | You need a Proxy/softswitch/SBC |
| 16:13.18 | drmessano | Asterisk doesn't cluster |
| 16:14.01 | drmessano | Best you can hope for is a A / B hot standby scenario |
| 16:14.09 | drmessano | warm standby |
| 16:14.23 | drmessano | luke-warm, maybe |
| 16:14.39 | drmessano | So A fails, B takes over |
| 16:14.43 | drmessano | Vice versa |
| 16:14.59 | drmessano | But you can't have both just handing calls without a proxy in front |
| 16:15.50 | Samot | Even then.. |
| 16:15.58 | Samot | calls and devices will drop when A fails and cuts over to B |
| 16:16.05 | drmessano | Well |
| 16:16.16 | drmessano | Yeah |
| 16:16.21 | drmessano | There's no handoff |
| 16:16.36 | drmessano | It's A or B, same config.. one dies, the other spins up and takes over |
| 16:16.54 | Samot | But the SIP channel on A isn't going to magically appear on B |
| 16:17.07 | Samot | So yeah, drops will happen. |
| 16:23.35 | *** join/#asterisk salviadud (~ralfalfa@189-211-190-134.static.axtel.net) |
| 16:28.05 | *** join/#asterisk Oatmeal (~Suzeanne@2600:1700:d0a1:85a0:fc6a:8ee9:e928:41a4) |
| 16:29.08 | *** join/#asterisk avb (~avb@45.55.203.176) |
| 16:30.45 | k3asd` | drmessano: pbx01 is master and pbx02 is a slave |
| 16:31.02 | k3asd` | drmessano: I don't want if both takes calls anymore |
| 16:31.30 | *** join/#asterisk defsdoor (~andy@cpc120600-sutt6-2-0-cust177.19-1.cable.virginm.net) |
| 16:31.43 | k3asd` | drmessano: doesn't matter if calls are dropped if pbx01 fails - I have the same configurations in both pbxs (it changes only the ip address) |
| 16:32.06 | RovingWriter | you have all phones registered to both pbx? |
| 16:32.33 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: no, just in one because the resource manager manage everything |
| 16:32.51 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: in the pbx02 asterisk isnt' started |
| 16:33.30 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: if pbx01 fails the resource manager is moving to pbx02 and the asterisk starts |
| 16:33.37 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: just in this situation |
| 16:34.07 | RovingWriter | interesting |
| 16:35.50 | avb | any new ways to syncronize queue status between 2 nodes in the cluster? :) |
| 16:36.59 | RovingWriter | build your own queing system? :) |
| 16:37.10 | avb | :) |
| 16:37.28 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: the exts seems register correctly and the outbound calls works fine |
| 16:37.41 | avb | RovingWriter: i were hoping for a better solution :) |
| 16:38.45 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: when the pbx receive a calls, IVR take it and when I press 1 or 2 and so on the calls need to be routed to correct ext - this doesn't work in this scenario |
| 16:39.04 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: same thing in an ext try to call another one - doesn't work in this scenario |
| 16:39.36 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: honestly I don't know and I'd like to understand why |
| 16:39.38 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 16:40.39 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: http://www.alexlinux.com/asterisk-high-availability-cluster-with-pacemaker-on-centos-7 |
| 16:41.20 | *** join/#asterisk EnrgySmth (d8eba104@gateway/web/freenode/ip.216.235.161.4) |
| 16:42.18 | avb | k3asd`: i think at the time of a failover to a pbx02 your phones are not registered to it |
| 16:42.37 | avb | im missing a part of the conversation, so i could say something stupid :) |
| 16:42.43 | RovingWriter | avb, i asked him if the phones were registered to both, and he didn't answer me |
| 16:43.00 | avb | im pretty much sure they dont :) |
| 16:43.21 | avb | and seems pacemaker do not share this info inside the cluster |
| 16:44.07 | RovingWriter | oh i guess he did answer me, he said no |
| 16:45.15 | k3asd` | avb: how can I find it? |
| 16:45.20 | avb | sip show peers |
| 16:45.30 | k3asd` | avb: I see all ext registered |
| 16:45.44 | RovingWriter | on both pbx? |
| 16:45.48 | k3asd` | avb: if I try an outbound call works fine |
| 16:45.52 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: no, just in one |
| 16:45.59 | *** join/#asterisk Dovid (~dovid@static-173-63-105-210.nwrknj.fios.verizon.net) |
| 16:46.02 | avb | :) |
| 16:46.06 | avb | on pbx01 |
| 16:46.10 | k3asd` | yes |
| 16:46.20 | k3asd` | I dont' want in both |
| 16:46.22 | avb | so when you getting calls on pbx02 -- nobody is there |
| 16:46.53 | avb | simple solution is to configure extensions to register to both nodes at the same time |
| 16:47.00 | avb | polycom support that easy |
| 16:47.05 | avb | linksys as well |
| 16:47.32 | k3asd` | avb: the resource manager takes one primary and one slave |
| 16:47.48 | k3asd` | avb: doesn't matter to have both active/active |
| 16:48.02 | avb | why? |
| 16:48.42 | avb | you do them active-active, and with pacemaker you share states and reassign floating ip to one of them on failure |
| 16:48.55 | k3asd` | avb: not exactly |
| 16:49.11 | k3asd` | avb: I have just one active with VIP and asterisk |
| 16:49.25 | k3asd` | avb: the issue I think is the resource manager |
| 16:49.36 | avb | in your case you can copy sqlite db from /var/lib/asterisk/ from master to slave before starting asterisk |
| 16:49.45 | k3asd` | avb: suppose I have 2 nodes, I setup pbx02 in standby mode |
| 16:50.03 | k3asd` | avb: now I have just pbx01 - isn't? ok good |
| 16:50.14 | avb | correct |
| 16:50.31 | k3asd` | avb: I if try sip show peers I see all phones registerd and trunk as well |
| 16:50.41 | avb | correct |
| 16:50.43 | k3asd` | avb: the outbound calls works correctly |
| 16:50.54 | k3asd` | avb: the inbound calls and ext to ext no |
| 16:51.53 | avb | after server just became master? |
| 16:52.53 | k3asd` | avb: no |
| 16:53.11 | k3asd` | avb: also after 30 minutes that the server is master |
| 16:53.29 | avb | incoming never works? |
| 16:53.44 | avb | what do you see in the log |
| 16:53.56 | avb | we are kinda discussing multiple problems at once |
| 16:53.58 | k3asd` | avb: incoming never works, that's right |
| 16:54.11 | RovingWriter | sounds like IVR works, but then any handoff to a phone does not |
| 16:54.17 | Samot | OK... |
| 16:54.23 | Samot | Guys. |
| 16:54.25 | *** join/#asterisk u0m3 (~u0m3@5-12-198-162.residential.rdsnet.ro) |
| 16:54.36 | Samot | There is going to be delays and drops. |
| 16:54.45 | k3asd` | avb: I hear the IVR voice menu and when I put 1, 2 or 3 the calls don'be routed |
| 16:54.52 | Samot | Of course. |
| 16:55.01 | k3asd` | RovingWriter: yes, it seems |
| 16:55.18 | Samot | PBX A and PBX B are sharing the same IP? |
| 16:55.23 | Samot | There's a floating IP between them? |
| 16:55.35 | k3asd` | Samot: yes, virtual ip |
| 16:55.52 | k3asd` | Samot: I'm using pacemaker, corosync and pcs |
| 16:55.58 | Samot | OK. |
| 16:56.05 | *** join/#asterisk wonderworld (~ww@151.68.139.140) |
| 16:56.16 | Samot | So you take PBX A down and then what? |
| 16:56.24 | Samot | Do the phones move to PBX B? |
| 16:56.36 | Samot | Do you seem them registering to PBX B? |
| 16:57.02 | Samot | See unless the phone is doing some sort of NAT keep-alive from itself, it just REGISTERs and that's it. |
| 16:57.45 | Samot | It won't re-attempt until the Register Expires is hit |
| 16:58.08 | Samot | Or it's rebooted/resynced |
| 16:58.16 | k3asd` | Samot: yes, if I set up pbx A down the resource moves correctly to pbx B |
| 16:58.32 | k3asd` | Samot: I see the ext registered |
| 16:58.32 | Samot | So all the phones register to PBX B? |
| 16:58.43 | k3asd` | Samot: the problem is the same as pbx A |
| 16:58.58 | k3asd` | Samot: outbound calls works, routed calls and ext to ext no |
| 16:58.58 | Samot | And how do the PBXes communicate with the provider? |
| 16:59.11 | Samot | Are you registering SIP trunks with them or using IP Auth/Peering? |
| 16:59.18 | k3asd` | Samot: I use trunk |
| 16:59.29 | Samot | So you register with them... |
| 16:59.37 | k3asd` | Samot: sure |
| 16:59.46 | Samot | And they allow multiple registreations? |
| 16:59.58 | Samot | On the same account? |
| 17:00.09 | k3asd` | Samot: consider if I remove clustering group (pacemaker and so on) the pbxs works correctly |
| 17:00.28 | Samot | Then this is an issue in your implentation. |
| 17:00.35 | Samot | Then this is an issue in your implementation. |
| 17:00.41 | k3asd` | Samot: I think so |
| 17:00.52 | k3asd` | Samot: I'd like to understand where |
| 17:01.32 | k3asd` | Samot: I don't have problem about multiple registrations because in pbx B asterisk is not started :) |
| 17:03.00 | k3asd` | Samot: if you want see some logs not a problem by myself |
| 17:06.09 | Samot | So what is the actual issue you are having with PBX A? |
| 17:06.22 | k3asd` | Samot: routing calls and ext to ext |
| 17:06.24 | avb | :) |
| 17:06.35 | avb | nice support case |
| 17:06.50 | avb | 30 minutes talking and still is not clear what is the problem is |
| 17:06.59 | avb | i love this work |
| 17:07.25 | drmessano | avb: You're not allowed to point that out |
| 17:07.38 | drmessano | Idiots will come and virtue signal you to death |
| 17:07.47 | avb | lol |
| 17:08.24 | drmessano | Also, it's been an hour |
| 17:08.38 | drmessano | 12:03 ET to 13:06 ET |
| 17:08.48 | drmessano | and still no idea what the problem is.. |
| 17:11.31 | k3asd` | drmessano: ahhaahhaha |
| 17:11.35 | Samot | What do you mean routing calls? |
| 17:11.38 | Samot | Or ext to ext? |
| 17:11.46 | Samot | Are the phones on the same local network? |
| 17:12.20 | drmessano | Samot: What part isn't clear |
| 17:12.24 | drmessano | Calls don't work |
| 17:12.32 | drmessano | Somewhere... |
| 17:12.38 | RovingWriter | never in the history of #asterisk, has a troubleshooting conversation gone so long without "post a fucking log" |
| 17:12.49 | Samot | Well |
| 17:12.57 | drmessano | RovingWriter: We don't know what to ask him to post |
| 17:13.00 | Samot | At first this was about floating IPs and heartbeats |
| 17:13.04 | drmessano | A log from what? |
| 17:13.07 | Samot | Not much in the Asterisk logs for that |
| 17:13.14 | drmessano | We don't even know... well.. |
| 17:13.24 | Samot | So, I will ask for a log when a log is needed. |
| 17:13.34 | drmessano | "Doctor it hurts" |
| 17:13.42 | drmessano | "what hurts?" |
| 17:13.48 | drmessano | "IT!!!!111!!!11!!" |
| 17:14.22 | drmessano | RovingWriter: CALLS FIX PLZ |
| 17:14.32 | RovingWriter | im not criticizing you, Samot. you are awesome :-) |
| 17:14.36 | eric_hill | Somebody post a log. |
| 17:14.44 | drmessano | ANYBODY |
| 17:14.47 | drmessano | OF ANYTHING |
| 17:14.53 | drmessano | FOR THE LOVE OF PETE |
| 17:15.08 | k3asd` | Samot: yes, same network |
| 17:15.10 | *** join/#asterisk dcae (4acc4c49@gateway/web/freenode/ip.74.204.76.73) |
| 17:15.18 | dcae | hi |
| 17:15.26 | drmessano | dcae: PLEASE POST A LOG |
| 17:15.26 | Samot | So you have the PBX behind NAT? |
| 17:15.27 | drmessano | NOW |
| 17:15.36 | k3asd` | Samot: sure |
| 17:15.38 | drmessano | dcae: sorry |
| 17:15.42 | Samot | Sure? |
| 17:15.46 | Samot | It's a yes/no question |
| 17:15.54 | k3asd` | Samot: yes |
| 17:15.56 | Samot | "Sure" = "Not sure but Sure" |
| 17:15.59 | drmessano | Samot: You got it, buddy |
| 17:16.05 | eric_hill | ^ lol |
| 17:16.35 | drmessano | It's definitely got a router in front of it somewhere |
| 17:16.40 | drmessano | 100% |
| 17:17.06 | salviadud | Ah, the nuisance of network topologies |
| 17:17.26 | drmessano | salviadud: Nah |
| 17:17.35 | drmessano | Netwerks r ez pz |
| 17:17.40 | drmessano | <----- packet ------> |
| 17:17.59 | drmessano | <----- packet ------> WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE <---- router ----> |
| 17:18.03 | k3asd` | brb |
| 17:18.21 | drmessano | Until |
| 17:18.24 | eric_hill | drmessano, you're missing the [magic happens here] section |
| 17:18.36 | salviadud | hehe, love the grafx |
| 17:19.25 | avb | Samot: have you been working with corosync togeather with asterisk before? |
| 17:19.34 | drmessano | eric_hill: Explaining the internet is really easier than most people think |
| 17:19.39 | drmessano | 1. Pack it |
| 17:19.41 | drmessano | 2. Send it |
| 17:19.45 | drmessano | 3. ?????? |
| 17:19.49 | drmessano | 4. Faceboobs |
| 17:19.54 | avb | Samot: does it resource manager really forwards registrations to a new master? |
| 17:19.55 | eric_hill | 5. Profit |
| 17:21.13 | drmessano | 6. Spend the next 10 years in hoodies flying around the word pretending that a guy from Harvard named "Zuck", who ripped off a business idea from other guys and made gajillions from it, isn't some kind of asshole and is really a philanthropist |
| 17:21.26 | drmessano | Thats my fav part |
| 17:21.31 | drmessano | #ZuckCares |
| 17:21.41 | dcae | can anybody help with a programming question related to chan_sip ? |
| 17:21.41 | salviadud | Yeah, he ripped them off |
| 17:22.13 | drmessano | Zuck cares about babies in the desert getting clean water |
| 17:22.25 | salviadud | Which desert? |
| 17:22.28 | salviadud | Flynt Michigan? |
| 17:22.29 | drmessano | All of them |
| 17:22.39 | drmessano | He's wordly AF dude |
| 17:22.43 | drmessano | He's worldly AF dude |
| 17:22.56 | salviadud | He should start with michigan, they have a lead crisis over there. |
| 17:23.01 | drmessano | Just look at all his Facebook spam |
| 17:23.06 | drmessano | About stopping hate |
| 17:23.08 | salviadud | The tap water is polluted |
| 17:23.11 | drmessano | and ending all the bad things |
| 17:23.25 | drmessano | salviadud: No, that's too easy |
| 17:23.35 | salviadud | He wants a step further and fix somalia or what |
| 17:23.38 | drmessano | He doesn't want to spend money to actually fix soemthing |
| 17:23.46 | Samot | avb: No. I have not. |
| 17:23.47 | drmessano | He wants to donate and plant a seed of love |
| 17:23.58 | Samot | I don't do setup like that |
| 17:24.12 | drmessano | Because you see |
| 17:24.20 | salviadud | Looks great on paper, is it because he might run for office or something stupid like that? |
| 17:24.23 | drmessano | A butterfly flapping its wings in Nova Scotia |
| 17:24.38 | drmessano | Makes a worm in Venezuela fertilize a flower |
| 17:24.44 | drmessano | Or something |
| 17:25.24 | Samot | ROFL |
| 17:25.25 | drmessano | salviadud: No, he's an insecure little prick that doesn't want the world to think he snorts coke daily with the Napster guy |
| 17:25.31 | salviadud | o/ I don't get it |
| 17:25.32 | *** join/#asterisk robink (~quassel@unaffilated/robink) |
| 17:25.33 | Samot | HE TIMEDOUT |
| 17:25.37 | drmessano | Shawn Fanning |
| 17:25.45 | Samot | So I'm sure his failover is wonderful. |
| 17:25.53 | drmessano | Samot: Its working fine |
| 17:25.54 | salviadud | Oh, I remember that part of the movie |
| 17:26.00 | drmessano | Failed. Over. |
| 17:26.00 | salviadud | He's really paranoid |
| 17:26.36 | salviadud | You think Zuck does coke? |
| 17:26.44 | Samot | What has been this thing with people wanting clustering for Asterisk? |
| 17:26.46 | drmessano | He spent years ripping dudes off, buying up smaller apps, and doing lines of coke off hookers backs, then he married an asian chick and decided to fix the world |
| 17:26.53 | eric_hill | dcae, don't ask if you can ask, just ask... |
| 17:26.56 | drmessano | Who the fuck? Does he think he's John Lennon? |
| 17:27.03 | drmessano | Lennon already did that schtick |
| 17:27.09 | salviadud | drmessano, that is very plausible. |
| 17:27.19 | salviadud | The coke on hooker's backs |
| 17:27.19 | dcae | eric_hill : here it goes: |
| 17:27.20 | dcae | i am using asterisk curl realtime to allow users to register |
| 17:27.26 | dcae | i was wondering how/where i should modify chan_sip so i make it send ipaddr on the registration request? |
| 17:27.30 | salviadud | With that kind of money |
| 17:27.31 | dcae | <PROTECTED> |
| 17:27.37 | salviadud | Wall street influenced |
| 17:27.38 | dcae | i edited channels/chan_sip.c in function realtime_peer_by_name , but it seems that for the initial registration request ipaddr is not set |
| 17:27.44 | dcae | i do get ipaddr for updates |
| 17:27.45 | drmessano | salviadud: When you're THAT rich.. you do lines off coke off dead hookers backs |
| 17:27.49 | dcae | but not for initial registration |
| 17:27.57 | dcae | any idea where i should look? |
| 17:28.02 | Samot | dcae: #asterisk-dev |
| 17:28.04 | salviadud | dead, because a living body doesn't cut it, hahaha |
| 17:28.09 | Samot | Because that's development |
| 17:28.13 | dcae | Samot: i already asked there, looks like nobody is around |
| 17:28.14 | Samot | This is not development support. |
| 17:28.15 | salviadud | I need it real stiff, so it doesn't move |
| 17:28.20 | Samot | OK. |
| 17:28.45 | Samot | You're modifying how Asterisk works. |
| 17:28.51 | Samot | We can't help with that. |
| 17:28.52 | drmessano | salviadud: It's kinda like.. if you're that rich.. you don't have a bong made out of a monkey skull.. you have one made out of a human skull |
| 17:28.54 | drmessano | Because you can |
| 17:29.07 | Samot | Because now you've modified how it works and how we know/expect it to work |
| 17:29.12 | drmessano | and not just some fossilized humans skull |
| 17:29.17 | salviadud | drmessano, that's just creepy |
| 17:29.52 | drmessano | salviadud: Rich people have islands where they hunt PEOPLE |
| 17:29.59 | salviadud | What sorta illuminati shennanigans is Zuck into now? |
| 17:29.59 | drmessano | Everyone knows that |
| 17:30.21 | salviadud | drmessano, I refuse to believe that! |
| 17:30.26 | drmessano | dude... |
| 17:30.31 | drmessano | Come on |
| 17:30.39 | drmessano | It's totally legit |
| 17:30.42 | salviadud | I mean, a private island, for human hunting? |
| 17:30.45 | drmessano | Yes |
| 17:31.01 | salviadud | Well, it is technically possible |
| 17:31.01 | drmessano | Maybe not even a whole island |
| 17:31.04 | drmessano | Just lots of land |
| 17:31.10 | drmessano | Away from it all |
| 17:31.20 | salviadud | But it has to be an island, since it is in international waters. |
| 17:31.25 | drmessano | ROFL |
| 17:31.28 | drmessano | Dude.. no |
| 17:31.34 | salviadud | And the laws of the united nations / any other country do not apply. |
| 17:31.37 | drmessano | When you're that rich |
| 17:31.41 | drmessano | You call the local sheriff |
| 17:31.53 | drmessano | Send him a pack of $100 bills |
| 17:32.06 | salviadud | Oh, you're talking about old fashioned curruption. |
| 17:32.07 | drmessano | Tell him you're hunting on Sunday and he should really go fishing |
| 17:32.09 | drmessano | and done |
| 17:32.12 | *** join/#asterisk Oatmeal (~Suzeanne@2600:1700:d0a1:85a0:fc6a:8ee9:e928:41a4) |
| 17:32.49 | salviadud | Trickle down economics has not favored us. |
| 17:33.12 | salviadud | It creates monsters with power. |
| 17:33.19 | salviadud | So, this monster now wants to fix the world. |
| 17:33.47 | salviadud | Well, with what you're saying, I don't believe him. |
| 17:33.52 | salviadud | He ain't fixing shit. |
| 17:36.21 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.157) |
| 17:42.04 | drmessano | Rght |
| 17:47.30 | *** join/#asterisk giesen (~ggiesen@2001:19f0:0:1019:5400:ff:fe25:bda6) |
| 17:50.08 | RovingWriter | so, I just went down to the vending machine in my building.... and on the way back, there is a blind guy trying to find the button for the elevator.. so i helped him out... and we're in the elevator and he asks "hows your day going?" im like "pretty good, just working! yours?" .. he's like "oh, good... hey, is it just me or is it really dark in here?" |
| 17:50.33 | *** join/#asterisk robink (~quassel@unaffilated/robink) |
| 17:50.50 | salviadud | He had a sense of humor |
| 17:50.54 | salviadud | good for him. |
| 17:53.21 | RovingWriter | yupyup |
| 17:53.41 | RovingWriter | i laughed and so did he |
| 17:55.13 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 17:57.19 | [TK]D-Fender | http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/967/175/0bf.jpg_large |
| 17:57.48 | salviadud | haha, shot the toaster |
| 18:02.54 | [TK]D-Fender | But I didn't shoot the deputy... |
| 18:04.19 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 18:22.02 | scgm11_ | Hi, Im trying to use the REGEXP in asterisk dialplan but I cant find the way to scape the correct chars |
| 18:22.08 | scgm11_ | my REGEXP ^\d{1,2}\*\d{1,2}\*\d{4} |
| 18:22.32 | scgm11_ | example: ${REGEX("^\\d\{1\,2\}\\*\\d\{1\,2\}\\*\\d\{4\}" 1*1*7412)} |
| 18:22.53 | scgm11_ | or other combinations but cant find the way to use it |
| 18:22.55 | scgm11_ | any idea? |
| 18:33.07 | eric_hill | Single backslash is permitted in the dialplan -> ${REGEX("^\d", $EXTEN)} |
| 18:33.25 | eric_hill | Don't use double-backslashes as you'll match \ only. |
| 18:33.59 | eric_hill | That said, I think you /do/ have to escape the braces. |
| 18:38.45 | *** join/#asterisk Oatmeal (~Suzeanne@2600:1700:d0a1:85a0:fc6a:8ee9:e928:41a4) |
| 18:41.56 | darkunderlord | So.. I used to use sip show channels to show me current codecs being used in a channel. PJSIP doesn't seem to have that same command. How can I get this for each endpoint or channel? |
| 18:56.39 | *** join/#asterisk overyander (~jeff@12.49.160.131) |
| 19:02.36 | Samot | pjsip show channels doesn't do that? |
| 19:09.27 | lvlinux | i think you have to do "pjsip show channel channelIDblahblah" for the details |
| 19:09.52 | Samot | Well no. |
| 19:10.09 | Samot | There is "pjsip show channel" and there is "pjsip show channels" |
| 19:10.18 | Samot | One shows a specific channel |
| 19:10.22 | Samot | One shows ALL the channels |
| 19:11.17 | lvlinux | yes but when you show them all it doesn't show the codec details |
| 19:15.12 | Samot | OK |
| 19:15.18 | Samot | Did you try looking at a specific channel? |
| 19:15.27 | Samot | Or did you even try "pjsip show channelstats"? |
| 19:25.17 | *** join/#asterisk cresl1n (Adium@asterisk/libpri-and-libss7-expert/Cresl1n) |
| 19:25.17 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o cresl1n] by ChanServ |
| 19:35.51 | darkunderlord | hmm not the stats one |
| 19:36.37 | darkunderlord | aww that's the trick :) thanks Samot |
| 19:38.33 | *** join/#asterisk TECFALL (~dschuett@38.121.113.66) |
| 19:38.55 | *** join/#asterisk k3asd` (~k3asd@unaffiliated/k3asd/x-0305612) |
| 19:39.23 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 19:39.27 | TECFALL | why am i getting a "Permission denied, deleting" when copying a .call file in /var/spool/asterisk/outbound? File has read write and execute by everyone. |
| 19:40.14 | [TK]D-Fender | Becaue you are never every supposed to COPY a file there |
| 19:40.20 | darkunderlord | TECFALL: the directory has those permissions? |
| 19:40.32 | TECFALL | no, the file |
| 19:40.38 | [TK]D-Fender | ---> MOVE ONLY <--- |
| 19:41.29 | Samot | No |
| 19:41.31 | Samot | Never copy |
| 19:41.40 | Samot | Asterisk reads that directory every second. |
| 19:41.47 | Samot | It will read half your call file in the copy |
| 19:41.50 | Samot | And done. |
| 19:41.52 | Samot | Failed. |
| 19:42.23 | Samot | Everything in callfiles document expressly say "Do not copy. Move" |
| 19:44.19 | TECFALL | ok, so now i'm getting "Operation not permitted" |
| 19:50.05 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@213-66-111-71-no148.tbcn.telia.com) |
| 19:50.30 | darkunderlord | I think you have to have root copy it over |
| 19:50.37 | darkunderlord | or whatever user asterisk is running as |
| 19:51.45 | Kunsi | MOVE. NOT COPY |
| 19:54.39 | Samot | Well it's linux |
| 19:54.40 | Samot | So yeah |
| 19:54.51 | Samot | You kinda need permission to move shit around into other directories. |
| 19:55.10 | Samot | The callfile needs to be own by the user running Asterisk |
| 19:55.33 | darkunderlord | lol sorry, eyah move |
| 19:55.34 | Samot | And that user can either move the file to the outgoing directory or anyone with superuser privileges can |
| 19:56.40 | Samot | TECFALL: You have to be root or the user Asterisk is running under. |
| 19:56.49 | Samot | Or some other user that can sudo |
| 19:59.59 | TECFALL | i just had to chown asterisk:asterisk and it is working now. |
| 20:00.10 | *** join/#asterisk tzafrir (~tzafrir@206.167.44.205) |
| 20:00.37 | TECFALL | However, i'm defining Context: my-context, but it is specifying that" "At least one of app or extension must be specified" |
| 20:02.02 | TECFALL | ah, just had to specify a bogus extension |
| 20:02.37 | Samot | What? NO |
| 20:02.38 | Samot | FFS |
| 20:02.56 | Samot | Channel: Local/<evten>@<context> |
| 20:03.02 | Samot | Where to SEND the originated call |
| 20:03.11 | Samot | Extension: <exten> |
| 20:03.19 | Samot | Context: <context> |
| 20:03.25 | Samot | Priority: <priority> |
| 20:03.33 | Samot | ^^ WHERE to send it when it is ANSWERED |
| 20:03.44 | Samot | It's not a bogus extension.. |
| 20:03.49 | Samot | You actually have to have it exist. |
| 20:04.00 | Samot | Did you not read the callfiles documemnts? |
| 20:05.12 | *** join/#asterisk J0hnSteel (~J0hnSteel@92.55.116.179) |
| 20:08.07 | *** join/#asterisk shanth (~shanth@45.77.82.49) |
| 20:28.37 | darkunderlord | LOL |
| 20:34.09 | *** join/#asterisk sommarnatt (~sommarnat@213-66-111-71-no148.tbcn.telia.com) |
| 20:49.46 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-50-32-101.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 21:01.47 | *** part/#asterisk kharwell (kharwell@nat/digium/x-tgmyyhchyzlehypm) |
| 21:43.13 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11_ (~scgm11@r186-50-13-51.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 21:55.08 | *** join/#asterisk [TK]D-Fender (~joe@64.235.216.2) |
| 22:17.58 | *** join/#asterisk scgm11__ (~scgm11@r186-50-30-75.dialup.adsl.anteldata.net.uy) |
| 22:18.03 | *** join/#asterisk kharwell (~kharwell@user-24-214-15-130.knology.net) |
| 22:18.03 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o kharwell] by ChanServ |
| 22:30.16 | lvlinux | anyone used a Teletronics SIP PSTN gateway? If so, what do you think of them. |
| 22:32.12 | *** join/#asterisk DivideBy0 (~DivideBy0@unaffiliated/divideby0x0) |
| 22:32.12 | *** mode/#asterisk [+o DivideBy0] by ChanServ |
| 22:38.01 | lvlinux | I just found out an old Multitech MultiVoIP 4 port gateway was starting to go bad on me at a customer site. |
| 23:22.57 | *** join/#asterisk O47m341 (~Suzeanne@2600:1700:d0a1:85a0:3ce2:77f2:d642:e31d) |
| 23:24.35 | *** part/#asterisk kharwell (~kharwell@user-24-214-15-130.knology.net) |
| 23:52.27 | *** join/#asterisk TandyUK (~admin@2a02:13a0:a006:1:b4f8:8786:220b:5d0f) |
| 23:52.49 | *** join/#asterisk fonefreak (~root@c-76-105-87-143.hsd1.ga.comcast.net) |
